Skip to main content
Preference Modeling/SETTLED/

Research: Political Influence as Strategic Substitution: Carbon Performance and Corporate Lobbying in US Climate Policy

ABSTRACT Firms facing environmental regulation can respond through both operational adjustment and political engagement, yet existing research provides limited insight into how these strategies interact. This study addresses the theoretical question of how firms allocate resources between market and nonmarket strategies and whether corporate lobbying functions as a complement to, or a substitute for, environmental abatement. Drawing on public choice theory, we argue that firms allocate resources across alternative strategies based on relative costs and expected benefits, such that firms with poor carbon performance, facing higher compliance costs, are more likely to substitute towards lobbying. We further propose that this relationship is contingent on the credibility of the regulatory environment. We test these arguments using panel data on US firms' carbon emissions and lobbying expenditures from 2010 to 2020, exploiting the US withdrawal from the COP21 Paris Agreement as an empirical setting capturing a broader class of deregulatory shocks. The results show that firms with higher emissions systematically engage in more lobbying and that this relationship weakens following the decline in climate accountability. This study contributes to the literature by conceptualising corporate lobbying as part of a strategic allocation between market and nonmarket responses, by identifying carbon performance as a key driver of firms' strategic behaviour and by demonstrating how changes in regulatory credibility shape the interaction between environmental performance and corporate political activity.

Current signal

Leaning Human

0 total evaluations · Watch the replay →

AI score

61

Human score

—

Human-AI gap

—

Preliminary signal. Fewer than five human judgments have been recorded, so this result may move substantially.

Your judgment is missing

Agree with the machine?

Vote across the five dimensions, see where you land against the crowd, and strengthen the public alignment dataset.

Cast your judgment